11 Copycat Homemade Halloween Candy Recipes

Now that it’s October, I’m in the mood to bake anything and everything apple, pumpkin and/or Halloween themed.  It is such a vibe and I couldn’t love it any more than I do!

Don’t get me wrong here, I’m a 12 year old at heart and love a good Halloween candy trick or treat, but the actual adult in me had this urge to recreate my own versions in the comfort of my own kitchen. There’s just something just so satisfying about DIY-ing and this was the perfect way to keep me occupied for hours (my boyfriend was thankful).

1. Homemade Butterfingers by Inside Bru Crew Life

Who knew that you could make your own butterfingers with just THREE ingredients? If you’ve got extra candy corn lying around the house (let’s face it’s more decor than something you eat), then this is the perfect way to make use of it!

Homemade Butterfingers - easy three ingredient candy bar copycat that everyone will devour. Great recipe to try for fall parties! #copycat #candybar #butterfingers #candycorn #peanutbutter #halloween #easy #recipe #fall #sweettreat

2. (Vegan) Candy Skull Crushers by Wallflower Kitchen

I mean, how cute are these? The fact that they are made with whole, healthy, vegan ingredients makes me love them even more! If you’re trying to ditch the artificial this Halloween, may we suggest whipping up a batch of skulls?

Candy Skull Crushers (Raw, Vegan + GF)

Want the Recipe?

3. No Bake Twix Bars by Pink Cake Plate

My obsession with Twix bars are REAL and this recipe had me ecstatic. So easy and scrumptious looking.

Want the Recipe?

4. Gluten Free Red Cherry Licorice (Twizzlers) by Gluten Free on a Shoe String

Another personal fav are pull and peel licorice (sadly, you don’t want to know the sh*t that’s in those). Do yourself a favor and make these crafty homemade versions!

Gluten Free Red Cherry Licorice

Want the Recipe?

5. Two Ingredient Homemade Nestle Crunch Bars by  The Decorated Cookie

You had me at 2 ingredients. Boom, done.

copycat recipe: HOMEMADE NESTLE CRUNCH CANDY BAR. 2-ingredients, easy, delicious chocolate with crispy cereal.

Want the Recipe?

6. Homemade Rolos by Oh She Glows

How stinkin’ cute are these? This is the perfect recipe to bring as a guest to any Halloween gathering.

homemade Rolo chocolate-7157

Want the Recipe?

7. Homemade Healthy Peanut butter Cups by Ambitious Kitchen

These are on repeat in our household. So damn simple and so DAMN GOOD.

8. Homemade Halloween Candy Bark by The Sweetest Occasion

What is holiday baking without a bark recipe? This is super simple and a good way to use up leftovers!

Halloween Candy Bark Recipe | Halloween party ideas, Halloween recipes and entertaining tips from @cydconverse

Want the Recipe?

9. Chewy Salted Caramels by Deliciously Yum

I mean, I can’t even look at these without wanting to take a bite.


Want the Recipe?

10. Scary Eyeballs by Taste of Home

This recipe is perfect for a kid’s party and will have you just as excited when making them.

Scary Eyeballs

Want the Recipe?

11. Halloween Walnuts by Culinary Hill

Take that extra bag of walnuts you have stuffed in the pantry and make them into a cute little Halloween treat! I absolutely love this creative idea and so will everyone at home!

These easy, adorable Halloween walnuts are coated in colorful candy melts and make a wholesome sweet treat. Add candy eyes for scary monsters or candy-coated chocolates for pumpkin stems. Your kids will definitely want to get in on the decorating fun, too! 

Want the Recipe?

Recent Posts

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Want to have FIRST access to the app along with exclusive recipes, meal plans, grocery lists, and discount codes sent directly to your inbox?


fall ravioli recipescalloped potatoes